Middle Island, NY Analytics

January recorded 84 crime incidents.

December recorded 64 crime incidents.

November recorded 96 crime incidents.

Theft
Robbery
Burglary
Vandalism
Shooting
Arson
Arrest
Assault
Other
024681012141618202224262830012345678910
11/2025
12/2025
01/2026
244Total

Crime Types

  • Other: 70
  • Arrest: 66
  • Theft: 57
  • Vandalism: 31
  • Assault: 12
  • Burglary: 4
  • Robbery: 2
  • Shooting: 2
  • Arson: 0

Crime by Month

In the past three months, November had the most number of crimes in Middle Island, New York.

November had about 2% more crime than December, with November producing 32 more crimes than December.

November had about 1% more crime than January, with November producing 12 more crimes than January.

Most Committed Crimes in Middle Island, New York

Over the past three months, Arrest was the most committed crime overall making up about 27% of crime in Middle Island, New York.

The most committed violent crime was Assault, making up about 86% of violent crime in Middle Island, New York.

The most committed property crime was Theft, making up about 93% of property crime in Middle Island, New York.

Reported Shootings in Middle Island, New York

We recorded 2 shootings over a three month period in Middle Island, New York. That's an average of about 0.667 shootings per month. January saw the most shootings with 1, followed by November with 1 shootings, and December with 0 shootings.

Disclaimer: SpotCrime pulls from multiple sources including news reported incidents. A majority of the crime incidents are directly from local police agencies. Occasionally, there may be duplicate crimes. The status of the crime is subject to change.

We are not the FBI. These are not official FBI numbers.

Data is based on a radius around the center point of Middle Island. This may include crimes from adjacent agencies and agencies within the area.