Cattaraugus, NY Area Cold Cases
Name
Betty McClellanAge
Cause of Death
GunshotInfo
He was shot two times in the neck and jawAgency
Pennsylvania Crime Stoppers
Name
Robert AllisonAge
42Cause of Death
MissingInfo
MissingAgency
Pennsylvania Crime Stoppers
Name
Sandra LubbertAge
Cause of Death
HomicideInfo
HomicideAgency
Pennsylvania Crime Stoppers
Name
Robert GaurrichAge
Cause of Death
GunshotInfo
GunshotAgency
Pennsylvania Crime Stoppers
Name
Caralee PensylAge
Cause of Death
HomicideInfo
The victim’s nude, decomposed body was foundAgency
Pennsylvania Crime Stoppers
Name
Walter KupryczukAge
33Cause of Death
GunshotInfo
Gunshot woundAgency
Pennsylvania Crime Stoppers
Name
Barbara SoltAge
27Cause of Death
MurderedInfo
MurderedAgency
Pennsylvania Crime Stoppers
Name
Sandra MillerAge
Cause of Death
StabbInfo
Stab woundAgency
Pennsylvania Crime Stoppers
Name
Timothy GreenAge
62Cause of Death
MissingInfo
MissingAgency
Pennsylvania Crime Stoppers
Name
Ada GroomesAge
54Cause of Death
HomicideInfo
HomicideAgency
Pennsylvania Crime Stoppers
Name
William ComerAge
Cause of Death
StabbInfo
Stab woundAgency
Pennsylvania Crime Stoppers
Name
Louisa KrenzelAge
Cause of Death
GunshotInfo
Gunshot woundAgency
Pennsylvania Crime Stoppers
Name
Thomas DeanAge
Cause of Death
StabbInfo
His motorcycle was intentionally struck by a dark green large square shaped suv displaying a yellow license plate. thomas lawrence dean was killed as a result of injuries sustained from the crash of his motorcycleAgency
Pennsylvania Crime Stoppers
Name
Beth BodenschatzAge
Cause of Death
GunshotInfo
Gunshot woundAgency
Pennsylvania Crime Stoppers
Name
Steven KachonikAge
Cause of Death
GunshotInfo
Gunshot woundAgency
Pennsylvania Crime Stoppers
Name
Harry MitchellAge
Cause of Death
GunshotInfo
Gunshot woundAgency
Pennsylvania Crime Stoppers
Name
Albert CopperAge
34Cause of Death
MissingInfo
MissingAgency
Pennsylvania Crime Stoppers
Name
Dale KerstetterAge
52Cause of Death
MissingInfo
MissingAgency
Pennsylvania Crime Stoppers
Name
Denise MillerAge
20Cause of Death
StabbInfo
Stab woundAgency
Pennsylvania Crime Stoppers
Name
Gregory MerayAge
Cause of Death
StrangulationInfo
Gregory meray died because of asphyxia due to carbon monoxide poisoning, the fire was determined to be intentionally set and gregory meray’s death was ruled a homicideAgency
Pennsylvania Crime Stoppers
Name
Scott FosnaughtAge
15Cause of Death
StabbInfo
Had been struck by a vehicle(s)Agency
Pennsylvania Crime Stoppers
Name
Shawn BaurAge
15Cause of Death
StabbInfo
Had been struck by a vehicle(s)Agency
Pennsylvania Crime Stoppers
Name
John HarvatAge
Cause of Death
GunshotInfo
Gunshot woundAgency
Pennsylvania Crime Stoppers
Name
Marjorie WestAge
4Cause of Death
MissingInfo
MissingAgency
Pennsylvania Crime Stoppers
Name
Billy JamesAge
Cause of Death
GunshotInfo
Gunshot woundAgency
Pennsylvania Crime Stoppers
Name
Michael AuteriAge
Cause of Death
MissingInfo
MissingAgency
Pennsylvania Crime Stoppers
Name
Jean GoldmanAge
Cause of Death
GunshotInfo
Gunshot woundAgency
Pennsylvania Crime Stoppers
Name
Emerson CarbaughAge
64Cause of Death
MissingInfo
MissingAgency
Pennsylvania Crime Stoppers
Name
Denise PiersonAge
18Cause of Death
MurderedInfo
MurderedAgency
Pennsylvania Crime Stoppers
Name
Anna KaneAge
26Cause of Death
StrangulationInfo
StrangulationAgency
Pennsylvania Crime Stoppers
Name
Joline WittAge
Cause of Death
HomicideInfo
A forensic pathologist determined the cause of death to be violent homicideAgency
Pennsylvania Crime Stoppers
Name
Orie EshAge
Cause of Death
MurderedInfo
The unknown suspect(s) burned the victim’s residence while he was inside, causing his deathAgency
Pennsylvania Crime Stoppers
Name
William SharkeyAge
49Cause of Death
GunshotInfo
The victim’s body was severely burned and had been shot to deathAgency
Pennsylvania Crime Stoppers
Name
Debra WigginsAge
31Cause of Death
MurderedInfo
MurderedAgency
Pennsylvania Crime Stoppers
Name
Gary RednerAge
55Cause of Death
StabbInfo
Stab woundAgency
Pennsylvania Crime Stoppers
Name
Richard WimbishAge
49Cause of Death
GunshotInfo
Gunshot woundAgency
Pennsylvania Crime Stoppers
Name
James Lloyd SrAge
65Cause of Death
GunshotInfo
Gunshot woundAgency
Pennsylvania Crime Stoppers
Name
Kelly McBrideAge
22Cause of Death
HomicideInfo
HomicideAgency
Pennsylvania Crime Stoppers
Name
Ryan KempAge
30Cause of Death
MissingInfo
MissingAgency
Pennsylvania Crime Stoppers
Name
David GrossAge
21Cause of Death
StrangulationInfo
StrangulationAgency
Pennsylvania Crime Stoppers
Name
Gail SchultzAge
18Cause of Death
StabbInfo
Stab woundAgency
Pennsylvania Crime Stoppers
Name
Paul SchultzAge
12Cause of Death
StabbInfo
Stab woundAgency
Pennsylvania Crime Stoppers
Name
Frances KieferAge
44Cause of Death
MissingInfo
MissingAgency
Pennsylvania Crime Stoppers
Name
Rose HnathAge
Cause of Death
StabbInfo
Stab woundAgency
Pennsylvania Crime Stoppers
Name
Sharon BrantweinerAge
19Cause of Death
StrangulationInfo
StrangulationAgency
Pennsylvania Crime Stoppers
Name
John MitchellAge
58Cause of Death
MissingInfo
MissingAgency
Pennsylvania Crime Stoppers
Name
John BealerAge
50Cause of Death
MissingInfo
MissingAgency
Pennsylvania Crime Stoppers
Name
Robert Freeman SrAge
Cause of Death
StabbInfo
Stab woundAgency
Pennsylvania Crime Stoppers
Name
Eric PylesAge
12Cause of Death
MissingInfo
MissingAgency
Pennsylvania Crime Stoppers
Name
Jeffrey HorwithAge
Cause of Death
MurderedInfo
MurderedAgency
Pennsylvania Crime Stoppers