Frisco, CO Area Cold Cases
data:image/s3,"s3://crabby-images/7c739/7c7397d54ecf1f5ed1af27576565e81ec348699d" alt="cold-case-record__Cullinan"
Name
Susan CullinanAge
34Cause of Death
HomicideInfo
On april 6, 1986, while visiting a friend ms. Cullinan was shot. Anyone with information regarding this case, is asked to please contact the frisco police department.Agency
Frisco Police Departmentdata:image/s3,"s3://crabby-images/7293b/7293b70b2f6d657086a892f74600546e2c45b3b5" alt="cold-case-record__Cunningham"
Name
Julie CunninghamAge
26Cause of Death
MissingInfo
26 year old julie cunningham was last seen in vail, colorado on march 15, 1975. She disappeared early in the evening after she left her apartment in the apollo park neighborhood to visit a local tavern. She was last seen wearing a brown suede jacket, blue jeans, a ski cap, and boots. She has never been heard from again. Although never charged in her case, serial killer ted bundy confessed to cunningham's murder. Bundy stated that he lured her into his vehicle by posing as an injured skier on crutches and asking her to help carry his ski boots. He claims he knocked her unconscious, drove her to a remote area about eighty miles west of vail and raped her. He states he strangled her and then disposed of her body in a shallow grave near rifle, co in a high desert area with a circular drive and some large trees. Her body was never found, however. Anyone with information regarding this case is asked to please contact the vail police department.Agency
Vail Police Departmentdata:image/s3,"s3://crabby-images/5c69e/5c69ed0d56fa406998d882402949669873c443b7" alt="cold-case-record__Rascon-Avila"
Name
Jose Rascon-AvilaAge
45Cause of Death
MissingInfo
Jose rascon-avila was last seen in 2009, and has not contacted family since. Mr. Rascon-avila is believed to be in arizona. Anyone with information regarding this case is asked to please contact the silverthorne police department.Agency
Silverthrone Police Departmentdata:image/s3,"s3://crabby-images/7c739/7c7397d54ecf1f5ed1af27576565e81ec348699d" alt="cold-case-record__Webb"
Name
Alvie WebbAge
86Cause of Death
MissingInfo
Alvie webb went missing while hunting in montezuma county, colorado. He was last seen wearing orange hunting clothing. Anyone with information regarding this case is asked to please contact the montezuma county sheriff's office.Agency
Montezuma County Sheriff's Officedata:image/s3,"s3://crabby-images/7bdb7/7bdb722c5e5512ac4462200e31adf0956a7d81b4" alt="cold-case-record__Schrup"
Name
Samuel SchrupAge
35Cause of Death
MissingInfo
On august 8, 2009, 35 year old samuel schrup's vehicle was found abandoned on shrine pass road in eagle county, colorado. There was a campsite set up in the area of the vehicle. The vehicle had dust and pine cone needles on it, so it appeared to have been there for some time. There was a hand written journal in the vehicle, the entry stated; "About to hike a hill. See you after". A search including use of a k-9 with rescue found nothing. Anyone with information regarding this case is asked to please contact the eagle county sheriff's office.Agency
Eagle County Sheriff's Officedata:image/s3,"s3://crabby-images/a6ac3/a6ac3319993b89218736851d3f3ec33956af307e" alt="cold-case-record__Garcia"
Name
Jose GarciaAge
30Cause of Death
HomicideInfo
Found on I-70, multiple gunshot wounds. Was a mexican national traveling to mexico.Agency
Jefferson County Sheriffdata:image/s3,"s3://crabby-images/2660d/2660d64f7fe8e211854200bcc72c68cc92971650" alt="cold-case-record__Alderton"
Name
James AldertonAge
47Cause of Death
HomicideInfo
On february 19, 1997 at about 11:30 am, three hunters were hunting for mountain lions with a dog when they discovered the remains of who was later identified as james dean alderton. Alderton's remains were found about four tenths of a mile up gilson gulch, north of idaho springs. The body was nearly completely skeletonized. The medical examiner later determined that apart of the body had evidence of a gunshot wound. Anyone with information regarding this case, is please asked to contact clear creek county sheriff's office.Agency
Clear Creek County Sheriff's Officedata:image/s3,"s3://crabby-images/2f527/2f52778cfcfb9a02f11e79ebfc6a957e6fbf1b27" alt="cold-case-record__Flores"
Name
Jeremy FloresAge
18Cause of Death
HomicideInfo
Anyone with information regarding this case, is asked to please contact the clear creek county sheriff's office.Agency
Clear Creek County Sheriff's Officedata:image/s3,"s3://crabby-images/3db6d/3db6d832725c2ca58a0517cec45ef4f752e6e07b" alt="cold-case-record__Halford"
Name
Norma HalfordAge
21Cause of Death
MissingInfo
21 year old norma halford was last seen on august 24, 1979 in georgetown, colorado. Her vehicle was found abandoned 6.4 miles up guanella pass road on august 22, 1979 and tagged by the colorado state patrol. Norma and her personal belongings have not been seen since. Anyone with information regarding this case is asked to please contact the clear creek county sheriff's office.Agency
Clear Creek County Sheriff's Officedata:image/s3,"s3://crabby-images/2d722/2d722c4cd3cd2fbff20c186bbfd84361a90f174c" alt="cold-case-record__Kaesik"
Name
John KaesikAge
43Cause of Death
HomicideInfo
On july 14, 1993, john kaesik was found off an embankment 7.7 miles south of idaho springs on highway 103. He had been shot in the head. During the course of the investigation it was determined kaesik was a low level drug dealer, dealing in marijuana and cocaine and may have been involved in a drug deal at the time of his death. His vehicle, a black gmc jimmy, was found by wheat ridge police at I-70 and kipling on september 7, 1993. John was known to frequent the cinch bar located at that time at 8101 washington street, adams county colorado. Anyone with information regarding this case, is asked to please contact the clear creek county sheriff's office.Agency
Clear Creek County Sheriff's Officedata:image/s3,"s3://crabby-images/8d032/8d0329acacc8bd839be237ed38ca41c45a8c0d09" alt="cold-case-record__Lenihan"
Name
John LenihanAge
73Cause of Death
MissingInfo
73 year old john lenihan vanished september 10, 1994 on a colorado vacation. On september 10 clear creek county sheriff's deputies found mr. Lenihan's abandoned rental car at the cloudland picnic area, about four miles east of colorado highway 103. He was last seen wearing a light green short-sleeved t-shirt, yellow shorts, and glasses. Anyone with information regarding this case is asked to please contact the clear creek county sheriff's office.Agency
Clear Creek County Sheriff's Officedata:image/s3,"s3://crabby-images/bccad/bccad626cc1f6715b0ab95e3a274a15215b454cd" alt="cold-case-record__Reinhard"
Name
Keith ReinhardAge
50Cause of Death
MissingInfo
50 year old keith reinhard of algonquin, illinois, was a daily herald sports writer for 22 years with a passion for covering high school sports. Mr. Reinhard had taken a 90 day leave of absence from the herald to work, write, reflect and regenerate in the colorado town of silver plume, 70 miles west of denver. He disappeared in colorado on august 7, 1988. During that summer, mr. Reinhard lived in a small apartment in the back of an abandoned catholic church and rented a tiny shop where he sold matted photographs. He also worked on a novel he was writing. Friends described mr. Reinhard as a free spirit and said his interest in photography and in panning for gold in colorado rivers took him west. Mr. Reinhard went to colorado alone, leaving his wife of three years at home. Around 5pm on august 7, mr. Reinhard announced he was heading into the mountains for a brief hike, in the area south of interstate 70. He was last seen wearing casual clothing and gym shoes. Mr. Reinhard said that he was going to hike to the top of pendleton mountain. He failed to return at 10pm as scheduled. A day later, when mr. Reinhard had not returned, a massive ground and air search began. The official search for him was called off august 14, 1988, after hundreds of searchers (one of them killed when his small plane crashed in the rocky terrain) logged more than 10,000 man-hours without finding a single clue. Anyone with information regarding this case is asked to please contact the clear creek county sheriff's office.Agency
Clear Creek County Sheriff's Officedata:image/s3,"s3://crabby-images/5a7db/5a7db0ce6b247737f096326c122eb0770072bbc0" alt="cold-case-record__Robertson"
Name
Shelley RobertsonAge
24Cause of Death
HomicideInfo
On august 21, 1975, reporting parties had entered the willie mae mine, approximately one mile east of berthoud falls, co, and smelled decaying material. On august 23, 1975 the reporting parties returned to the willie mae mine and discovered a body, later identified as shelley kay robertson. Anyone with information regarding this case, is asked to please contact the clear creek sheriff's office.Agency
Clear Creek County Sheriff's Officedata:image/s3,"s3://crabby-images/dd75f/dd75f2f14cc70854c7cb7ef4712e69e44b800d4d" alt="cold-case-record__Anderson"
Name
Keith AndersonAge
23Cause of Death
HomicideInfo
February 5, 1984 keith anderson was last seen at a horse barn in grand county, colorado. Mr. Anderson boarded his horse at the barn, he has never been heard from again. His truck was found idling near the barn with his german shepherd dog in the back. Police later found some of his blood in the barn, and after his disappearance, witnesses reported hearing several gunshots in the area. Anyone with information regarding this case, is asked to please contact the grand county sheriff's office.Agency
Grand County Sheriff's Officedata:image/s3,"s3://crabby-images/41e9f/41e9f6cbc9d8e1681562b88255764b6a2d870811" alt="cold-case-record__Lepik"
Name
James LepikAge
54Cause of Death
HomicideInfo
Anyone with information regarding this case, is asked to please contact the grand county sheriff's office.Agency
Grand County Sheriff's Officedata:image/s3,"s3://crabby-images/1a74a/1a74a3f75420c3235091c8ae4fc7b0eccca4a13a" alt="cold-case-record__Anderson"
Name
Keith AndersonAge
22Cause of Death
MissingInfo
On february 5, 1984 keith anderson was last seen at a horse barn in grand county, colorado. Mr. Anderson boarded his horse at the barn, he has never been heard from again. His truck was found idling near the barn with his german shepherd dog in the back. Police later found some of his blood in the barn, and after his disappearance, witnesses reported hearing several gunshots in the area. Anyone with information regarding this case, is asked to please contact the grand county sheriff's office.Agency
Grand County Sheriff's Officedata:image/s3,"s3://crabby-images/8a5ee/8a5ee9c71fbebf14f9c39fe87a0f8607a1f19843" alt="cold-case-record__Oberholtzer"
Name
Barbara OberholtzerAge
30Cause of Death
HomicideInfo
Ms. Oberholtzer was last seen at 7:50 p.M. On wednesday, january 6, 1982 hitchhiking south out of the town of breckenridge, colorado. Ms. Oberholtzer's body was located approximately 3:00 p.M. The next day on january 7, 1982 on the summit of hoosier pass at 11,000+ feet elevation. A small parking lot is located at the pass summit and the body was found approximately 300 feet further south along the road to fairplay, colorado. The summit is approximately 10 miles south of breckenridge, colorado along colorado state highway 9. The shooting occurred outside in a rural, isolated, mountain area next to colorado highway 9. It would have been dark, possibly snowing, and very cold (-20 degrees f). Death was due to loss of blood from a gunshot wound of the chest, with a second grazing wound to the right breast, and appeared to have occurred at the location of the body. The body was found approximately 20 feet off of the highway, down a snow embankment, and was lying on her back. Items from ms. Oberholtzer's back pack/purse were located approximately 20 miles from the crime scene along us highway 285 south and east toward denver, colorado. The weapon used was a .38/.357 handgun using a remington/peters copper jacketed hollow point bullet. This weapon has not been recovered. A copper jacket from ms. Oberholtzer;s body is available for comparison. Anyone with information regarding this case, is asked to please contact the park county sheriff's office or visit www.Rockymountaincoldcase.ComAgency
Park County Sheriff's Officedata:image/s3,"s3://crabby-images/e0b0e/e0b0e357fdffa9e31511d253bf4659160ddb7bf5" alt="cold-case-record__Schnee"
Name
Annette SchneeAge
22Cause of Death
HomicideInfo
The victim was last seen hitchhiking south from the town of breckenridge. Ms. Schnee was last seen at approximately 4:45 p.M. On wednesday january 6, 1982. Ms. Schnee's body was located 6 months after her disappearance/death on july 3, 1982 in rural park county, colorado approximately 20 miles south of breckenridge. She was shot outside in a rural, isolated, mountain valley area where there would be no witnesses. It would have been dark, possibly snowing, and very cold (-20 degrees f). The death was due to loss of blood from a single gunshot wound to the back, and appeared to have occurred at the location where the body was found. The body was found face down in a small stream, fully clothed, but with clothing in disarray. Cold weather and cold water preserved the body for an autopsy. The weapon used was possibly a .38/.357/9 mm handgun. No bullet was found in the body. Anyone with information regarding this case, is asked to please contact the park county sheriff's office or visit www.Rockymountaincoldcase.ComAgency
Park County Sheriff's Officedata:image/s3,"s3://crabby-images/7c739/7c7397d54ecf1f5ed1af27576565e81ec348699d" alt="cold-case-record__Blair"
Name
Michael BlairAge
33Cause of Death
MissingInfo
Michael blair has been missing from fairplay, colorado since january 30, 2020. Anyone with information regarding this case is asked to please contact the park county sheriffs office.Agency
Park County Sheriff's Officedata:image/s3,"s3://crabby-images/7c739/7c7397d54ecf1f5ed1af27576565e81ec348699d" alt="cold-case-record__Watkins"
Name
Tommy WatkinsAge
27Cause of Death
HomicideInfo
Anyone with information regarding this case, is asked to please contact the lake county sheriff's office.Agency
Chaffee County Sheriff's Officedata:image/s3,"s3://crabby-images/7c739/7c7397d54ecf1f5ed1af27576565e81ec348699d" alt="cold-case-record__Lilly"
Name
Patricia LillyAge
43Cause of Death
MissingInfo
Patricia ann lilly was last seen at bison mountain 94 in fairplay, colorado on october 5, 1980. Anyone with information regarding this case is asked to please contact the park county sheriff's office.Agency
Park County Sheriff's Officedata:image/s3,"s3://crabby-images/b427a/b427a7fd25f3e5bf8b1d5f3a97803cf38be4247b" alt="cold-case-record__Knuth"
Name
Tereasa KnuthAge
23Cause of Death
MissingInfo
23 year old tereasa knuth was camping with her boyfriend, fred calkins, when he reported her missing on august 24, 1981. Knuth left behind her identification, cigarettes, and other personal items. No traces of knuths whereabouts were found in the area or at the campsite. Extensive searches of the area have been performed over the years and yielded no new leads. Anyone with information regarding this case is asked to please contact the summit county sheriff's office.Agency
Summit County Sheriff's Officedata:image/s3,"s3://crabby-images/a7a57/a7a57c3d71ada059e5dc812a52712d7edb987a3c" alt="cold-case-record__McClure"
Name
Michael McClureAge
30Cause of Death
MissingInfo
30 year old michael mcclure was last seen in cannon city, colorado on november 26, 1990. Michael mcclure's roommate reported him missing when mcclure never returned home to their wildernest condo. Mcclure had called in sick to his plumbing job the day before, and his roommate hadn't seen or heard from him in more than 36 hours. Mr. Mcclure has a history of depression and may have been suicidal. He was last seen wearing a light tan jacket, blue jeans, tennis shoes, and glasses. Mcclure was driving his 1972 gold-painted four-door chevrolet chevelle, which had colorado license plates wpx-187. His vehicle has never been located. Foul play is suspected. Anyone with information regarding this case is asked to please contact the summit county sheriff's office.Agency
Summit County Sheriff's Officedata:image/s3,"s3://crabby-images/01458/014589407d47f605a8f6f683131a0c7d43795a22" alt="cold-case-record__Reynolds"
Name
Peggy ReynoldsAge
21Cause of Death
MissingInfo
Peggy reynolds was last seen in silverthrone, colorado on april 4, 1974. She was last seen wearing a dark blue turtleneck, a plaid shirt, blue corduroy pants, white undergarments, brown hiking boots, a red bandanna, a gold wedding band, and possibly earrings. She was carrying a st. Christoper key ring with keys. The jacket that ms. Reynolds was wearing was recovered by searchers. Anyone with information regarding this case is asked to please contact summit county sheriff's office.Agency
Summit County Sheriff's Officedata:image/s3,"s3://crabby-images/dd4bc/dd4bc62b13addc75b1fd20559e2a25b34193adda" alt="cold-case-record__Stratinas"
Name
Nikolaos StratinasAge
27Cause of Death
HomicideInfo
On january 29, 1986, nikolaos stratinas spoke to his family overseas by phone, this was the last time he was known to have been heard from alive. Nikolaos stratinas was reported as a missing person from arapahoe county on february 18, 1986. Nikolaos stratinas was found ten days later, 5 miles north of silverthorne, colorado, just feet from state highway 9. Evidence at the scene suggested nikolaos stratinas' body had been placed in that location some time after he died. Nikolaos stratinas' cause of death was a gunshot wound to the head. If you have any information regarding this case, please call the summit county sheriff's office.Agency
Summit County Sheriff's Office